When reading about the rumors surrounding Goryokaku, Shiryokaku, and Matsumae Castle, stories of sounds and human figures are often interwoven with explanations of war and construction. Comparing documents from Hakodate City and Matsumae Town, some descriptions correspond to the historical aspects, while others cannot be verified due to insufficient documentation. This paper avoids equating the history of the historical sites with the current strange occurrences, and instead shows which claims could be compared and to what extent.
Survey methods and evaluation criteria
On November 7, 2026, we obtained the text of three entries in the National Haunted Map, as well as guides to historical sites and museums in Hakodate City and Matsumae Town. The five categories are judged for each claim, and parts of the city's explanations that are presented as folklore are treated as they are. The score is the sum of Source Transparency 30, Historical/Spatial Context 25, Safety Information 20, Novelty 15, and Rumor Source Transparency 10, and does not score the level of fear or danger. The images displayed are AI-edited images and are not actual photographs of historical sites or evidence of events.
| Rank | point | The main points of the rumor | judgement | Document quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | four ridges | The rumors about Shiryokaku include not only descriptions of soldiers but also details about the construction process. The source states that "construction was halted midway" after the war, and then continues... | unmeasurable | 88/100 |
| 2 | Goryokaku Ruins | The source of the information about the Goryokaku ruins connects the site to the "final battle of the Boshin War," and then mentions stories of "unexplained sounds at night" and "a male ghost appearing." The dance of war… | Partial match | 84/100 |
| 3 | Matsumae Castle | The source of the Matsumae Castle entry mentions a place within the castle grounds called the well, stating that "the well cannot be filled in no matter how hard you try" and "groans can be heard in the dark of night." Those who heard the sounds... | unmeasurable | 78/100 |
1st place: Shiryokaku|Unmeasurable (88 points)

The rumored details
The rumors surrounding Shirokaku include not only descriptions of soldiers but also details about the construction process. The source states that "construction was left unfinished" after the war, and then connects this to the story that "soldiers still appear there." In this article, we have examined whether this explanation of incompleteness aligns with the city's historical site guide, separate from the ghost stories.
Source of the rumor and date of verification
This refers to "Shiryokaku" from the nationwide paranormal map obtained on November 7, 2026. The theory that it was unfinished and the description of the soldiers are in the same text, but the historical materials that formed the basis of these explanations, as well as the original records of people who saw them, have not been identified. The source is indicated as a secondary publication.
- Nationwide Haunted Map - Shiryokaku(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — Construction is still incomplete / Soldiers are still being deployed
Things that could be confirmed from official and primary source materials
Hakodate City explains that Shiryokaku was a fort hastily constructed to protect the Hokkaido Toshogu Shrine, the guardian shrine of Goryokaku. Regarding its construction, it mentions local legend that soldiers and residents worked day and night to complete it in just a few days. Furthermore, it describes how the defenders retreated towards Goryokaku during the general attack, and does not explain that construction continued until the end of the war.
- Hakodate City - Shirokaku Historic Site(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — According to local legend, the former shogunate's rebel army mobilized 200 soldiers and about 100 local residents to complete this square fort in just a few days, working day and night. / No buildings were constructed. / *To prevent water pipes from freezing, the toilets and drinking fountains will be closed during the winter months.
Points of agreement/contradictions
Rumors assert that the construction was halted midway, but city documents present a tradition stating that "it is said to have been completed." Although there are discrepancies in the descriptions, the city also presents the circumstances of completion as local legend, and it is not possible to confirm the other fact of completion. Since there are no original records of the construction, we have deemed the claim of comparing completion and incompleteness to be unmeasurable.
| The rumored atomic claim | Matching results | reason | Corresponding documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| The construction work has also been stopped midway. | Unconfirmed | The city cites local legends that the construction was completed within a few days, but it has not obtained any original construction records. The difference between the legends and rumors alone is insufficient to determine whether the claim of incompleteness is true or false. | Hakodate City - Shirokaku Historic Site |
| Soldiers still come out today | Unconfirmed | There are no photographs or timestamps corresponding to current sightings, and therefore, comparisons cannot be made based on historical site descriptions. | No official data available for direct comparison. |
Alternative interpretation
It's possible that the absence of buildings on site contributed to the impression that the site was unfinished. However, I haven't been able to trace the history of how that impression came about. The city has explained that no buildings were constructed within the fortified area, so the absence of buildings does not necessarily mean that the entire fort was unfinished.
Scope and limitations of the investigation
We compared the city's historical site explanation with the rumor text, but did not obtain the original construction log or drawings. We also reserved the caveat that the city's explanation regarding the completion is based on legend. Original photographs, timestamps, and locations showing soldiers' eyewitness accounts remain unconfirmed as they are necessary additional materials.
Verification result: Unmeasurable
There are discrepancies between the rumored unfinished construction and the city's account of its completion. However, the presentation of the legend alone is insufficient as independent evidence to confirm the completion of the construction, and therefore cannot be used to determine a discrepancy. Since there are no direct records of soldiers' eyewitness accounts, neither claim can be measured.
Document Quality Score
| Source transparency | 28/30 | The city's historical site document summarizes the construction, war, and usage guidelines, and allows for direct comparison with the locations where rumors are posted. |
|---|---|---|
| Historical and spatial context | 23/25 | While you can compare differing accounts of completion and incompleteness, the city's explanation is based on oral tradition and does not definitively confirm the completion of the construction with independent sources. |
| Safety information | 19/20 | You can refer to the city's specific guidelines regarding slopes, earthworks, emergency vehicle entrances, and winter water facilities. |
| Newness of information | 12/15 | I obtained city documents on November 7th, but the publication date for the historical site explanation is 2023, so the exact time of the sighting is unknown. |
| Transparency of the source of rumors | 6/10 | While we can trace the construction description and rumors about the soldiers, the original historical source on which the description is based and the first recorded sighting are unknown. |
| total | 88/100 | This is the overall quality of the materials. It does not represent the degree of truthfulness or danger associated with the supernatural phenomena. |
Safety information and maps
Hakodate City has issued a warning about the steep slopes and prohibits climbing the embankment and damaging the grass. Please do not park at the entrance, as it is used for emergency vehicle access. In winter, the toilets will be closed and the water fountains will be shut off.
Map location: This is the representative location of the facility/park. It does not indicate the rumored location, land parcel, entrance, or accessible area.
2nd place: Goryokaku ruins | Partial match (84 points)

The rumored details
The source of the information about the Goryokaku ruins connects the site to the "final battle of the Boshin War," and then introduces stories of "unexplained sounds at night" and "a male ghost appearing." The explanation that it was the site of a war and the claims of what can be heard at night today cannot be verified with the same type of evidence. Therefore, I first compared it with historical records.
Source of the rumor and date of verification
The "Goryokaku Ruins" entry in the National Haunted Map was acquired on November 7, 2026. The data includes short rumor descriptions, and the page vote count is not used to represent confirmed sightings. Audio recordings, original images of the man, and the initial appearance of the experiences could not be identified at this time.
- Nationwide Haunted Map - Goryokaku Ruins(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — The final battle of the Boshin War / Unexplained sounds when visiting at night / A male ghost appears
Things that could be confirmed from official and primary source materials
Hakodate City's war history describes the Battle of Hakodate as the final battle of the Boshin War, detailing how the fighting extended not only to Goryokaku but also to the port and surrounding fortifications. The city also explains how the former shogunate forces that occupied Goryokaku surrendered and handed it over to the new government. Another overview page shows the structure of the earthworks, moats, and bridges, allowing readers to understand the current facility layout without confusing it with the scope of the war.
- Goryokaku Fort Ruins, a Special Historic Site, Hakodate City(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — As its name suggests, Goryokaku has five corners called bastions, forming a star-shaped pentagon.
- The War History of Goryokaku, Hakodate City(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — The Battle of Hakodate, the final battle of the Boshin War, has begun.
Points of agreement/contradictions
The fact that Goryokaku was involved in the final battle of the Boshin War aligns with the city's historical explanation. However, the scope of that battle cannot be narrowed down to just the current Goryokaku Park. Even if historical documents confirm its involvement in the war, the nighttime noises and the appearance of a male spirit remain separate claims and cannot be deduced from historical evidence.
| The rumored atomic claim | Matching results | reason | Corresponding documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| The final battle of the Boshin War | support | In its war history of Goryokaku, Hakodate City describes the Battle of Hakodate as the final battle of the Boshin War. This description is limited to its connection to the war itself and does not mean that the entire battle took place solely within the fort. | The War History of Goryokaku, Hakodate City |
| If you go there at night, you'll hear strange noises. | Unconfirmed | There are no audio records that can be used to verify what happened, when, and where, and the source of the sound cannot be determined from the city's war history. | No official data available for direct comparison. |
| A male ghost appears | Unconfirmed | The original images and dates have not been identified, so they cannot be used as evidence of a historical battle based on current eyewitness accounts. | No official data available for direct comparison. |
Alternative interpretation
To analyze the current sound, we need information such as the recording time, location, and surrounding activity. We must distinguish between the possibility that the battlefield's history influenced the interpretation of the sound and what the actual sound source was. Neither of these can be determined from the introductory text provided.
Scope and limitations of the investigation
We compared an overview of Hakodate City, the history of the Hakodate War, and external rumors. No nighttime recordings or on-site observations were conducted. Also, the map of the current location only shows the representative locations of historical sites and does not show the entire scope of the battle, the locations of individual events, or the origins of the rumors.
Verification results: Partial match
The connection between the rumors and the end of the Boshin War can be confirmed through city records. However, there are no original records of the sounds or appearances. This is a coincidence limited to historical elements and does not constitute a conclusion that the war caused the strange occurrences or that spirits appear at night.
Document Quality Score
| Source transparency | 28/30 | You can find information about the structure of Hakodate City and its war history on two official pages separate from the rumored introductory text. |
|---|---|---|
| Historical and spatial context | 24/25 | The relationship between Goryokaku and the Battle of Hakodate, as well as the progression of the battles that spread to the surrounding areas, can be distinguished using city documents. |
| Safety information | 15/20 | The structure of the moat and bridges can be understood from the documents, but the actual conditions of each facility on the day of the public opening need to be reconfirmed. |
| Newness of information | 12/15 | The city's webpage was published in 2023, and we confirmed it was reached on November 7th, but the timing of the observation of the nighttime rumors is unknown. |
| Transparency of the source of rumors | 5/10 | While the introductory text can be identified, direct recordings of sounds and appearances, as well as the initial testimony, cannot be confirmed. |
| total | 84/100 | This is the overall quality of the materials. It does not represent the degree of truthfulness or danger associated with the supernatural phenomena. |
Safety information and maps
Goryokaku is a historical site with earthen ramparts and a moat. Please view the site from designated areas such as bridges and pathways, and do not enter dangerous areas for purposes such as photographing the moat or exploring at night. Please check the latest management information for the conditions for visiting the park and buildings within the fort.
Map location: This is the representative location of the facility/park. It does not indicate the rumored location, land parcel, entrance, or accessible area.
3rd Place: Matsumae Castle | Unmeasurable (78 points)

The rumored details
The source of the Matsumae Castle information mentions a place within the castle grounds called a well, stating that "the well cannot be filled in no matter how hard you try" and "groans can be heard in the dark of night." This investigation has not been able to identify who heard the groans or the specific location of the well. This article focuses solely on that story and does not include other origin stories found on the same page.
Source of the rumor and date of verification
We acquired the entry for "Matsumae Castle" from the National Haunted Map on November 7, 2026. The entry is a secondary description of the well and the voices. Since we have not obtained any records of the construction work to fill in the well, nor any audio recordings or initial testimonies, we have distinguished between publishing the text and verifying the events.
- National Haunted Map - Matsumae Castle(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — The well cannot be filled in no matter how hard you try / Groans can be heard in the dark of night
Things that could be confirmed from official and primary source materials
According to the Matsumae Town Museum guide, Fukuyama Castle, also known as Matsumae Castle, was built by order of the shogunate. The remaining wooden keep was destroyed by fire in 1949, and a reinforced concrete reconstruction was completed in 1960. The museum opened the following year. The main gate is introduced as an architectural relic from the late Edo period, indicating that the various parts of the castle we see today are not from the same era.
- Highlights of Matsumae Town and Matsumae Castle Museum(Confirmed on 2026-11-07) — Fukuyama Castle is also known as Matsumae Castle. / A reinforced concrete reconstruction of the castle tower was completed in 1960. / It is the only remaining architectural structure of Fukuyama Castle, completed in the late Edo period. / Access is only via stairs.
Points of agreement/contradictions
The town records explain the burning and reconstruction of the castle tower and the history of the main gate, but they do not show the location of the well or the process of filling it in, as mentioned by the source. It cannot be interpreted that the town denied the story about the well, nor does the existence of a reconstructed castle tower provide evidence that the rumors are true. The task of identifying the current museum with the object referred to in the rumors remains.
| The rumored atomic claim | Matching results | reason | Corresponding documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| The well cannot be filled in no matter how hard you try. | Unconfirmed | We do not have records indicating the location of the well or the backfilling work, so we cannot verify the history solely from the museum's records. | No official data available for direct comparison. |
| Groans can be heard in the dark of night. | Unconfirmed | The original sound source and the date of observation are unknown, so the castle's history cannot be used as evidence for the sound. | No official data available for direct comparison. |
Alternative interpretation
It's possible that the old castle, the current keep, and other facilities within the castle grounds are being described as the same location. However, since the location of the well cannot be determined, we cannot conclude that this confusion actually occurred. As for the voices, there are no recordings to determine whether they were simply echoes caused by buildings or terrain.
Scope and limitations of the investigation
I compared the town's museum guide with the description of the rumored well. I did not cross-reference documents indicating the well's location, construction records, or on-site signboards. The map only shows the representative location of the castle and does not pinpoint the exact location of the well or the source of the sound. I have not included any other origins that I have not obtained as historical fact.
Verification result: Unmeasurable
While the history of the castle and museum can be confirmed, the well referred to in the rumors cannot be uniquely identified, and there are no records of it being filled in or any comparison of voices. This judgment is to avoid supporting the claim of a well solely based on the history of the castle tower, or dismissing it simply because there is no written record.
Document Quality Score
| Source transparency | 26/30 | While the town's museum guide can be distinguished from external rumors, there are no construction documents that directly deal with wells. |
|---|---|---|
| Historical and spatial context | 21/25 | While the history of the current reconstructed castle tower and the existing main gate of the citadel can be distinguished, the relationship with the well remains undetermined. |
| Safety information | 14/20 | The town has indicated that the facility is accessed via stairs, but a safe, publicly accessible route to the well has not been confirmed. |
| Newness of information | 12/15 | We obtained a guide to the town's attractions on November 7th, and this information is separate from the information provided on the day of entry. |
| Transparency of the source of rumors | 5/10 | While the description of the well is available, records of its backfilling and the first accounts of those who heard the voices cannot be provided. |
| total | 78/100 | This is the overall quality of the materials. It does not represent the degree of truthfulness or danger associated with the supernatural phenomena. |
Safety information and maps
The Matsumae Castle Museum is a facility where you move around via stairs, and the town guides visitors accordingly. Please follow the designated route and conditions during your visit, and do not enter restricted areas while searching for the well. Please also note that being able to see the exterior of the castle and being able to enter the museum are separate things.
Map location: This is the representative location of the facility/park. It does not indicate the rumored location, land parcel, entrance, or accessible area.
What I learned by crossing locations
Regarding the rumors about Goryokaku, we were able to confirm its connection to the Battle of Hakodate through city documents, but the fighting was not confined to the fort itself. The theory that Shiryokaku was unfinished differs from the legend and description of its completion presented by the city. However, that legend alone cannot confirm its completion and is insufficient as evidence of the discrepancy. At Matsumae Castle, while we were able to confirm the difference between the reconstructed keep and the existing remains, we could not identify the well in question. Understanding the detailed history of a historical site and identifying the source of sounds and appearances are two different achievements.
summary
The three historical sites yielded different results when we separated history from rumors. Goryokaku had some agreement regarding its involvement in the war, while Shiryokaku lacked sufficient documentation to determine its completion or incompleteness, making measurement impossible. The well at Matsumae Castle also lacked direct evidence. None of these judgments should be based solely on historical sources to confirm or deny the existence of spirits.
FAQ
Can the theory that Shirokaku was unfinished be disproven by city documents?
The city cites local accounts that the construction was completed within a few days, but it does not have original construction records. Since the discrepancy in the descriptions alone cannot negate the possibility that it was incomplete, this paper classifies the completion date as unmeasurable.
If the setting is a war zone, does that corroborate the current stories about spirits?
The history of the battle and current eyewitness accounts are separate claims. War history alone cannot provide evidence of nighttime sounds or people's movements. Original images, recordings, and documents with location and date information are needed separately.
Do the markers on the map indicate wells or sighting locations?
It is not shown. The map shows the representative locations of historical sites and facilities. The well at Matsumae Castle has not been identified and cannot be used to determine the entire extent of the battle, a single point of sighting, or the boundaries of areas that were permitted to enter.
Are there any points to be aware of before the tour?
Please be careful of the earthworks, moats, and steep slopes, and follow the designated public viewing route. There are parking restrictions at the entrance to Shirokaku, and cautions regarding the water facilities in winter. Visiting the museum is also subject to separate conditions from park usage.
How to read this article and safety precautions
" [2026 Latest] Top 3 Ranking of Ghostly Rumors at Goryokaku, Shiryokaku, and Matsumae Castle This is an article compiled by the Horror Tales File editorial team as a story, based on publicly available information, rumors circulating in the community, and information submitted by readers. It does not definitively state the authenticity of paranormal phenomena.
- We do not recommend visiting restricted areas, private property, abandoned buildings, or dangerous locations at night.
- If you go to the site, always prioritize compliance with laws and regulations, instructions from facility managers, and consideration for nearby residents.
- You can submit personal experiences, correction requests, and deletion requests through the "Personal Experiences/Information Submission" or "Contact Us" sections.
View editorial policy / Please share your experiences and information here. / inquiry
